Compensation Review

Compensation Review: When It Is Mandatory and How It Works

Pay Assessment (joint pay assessment) is an in-depth analysis that an employer must conduct if its pay gap report reveals a difference of 5% or more for a particular job group that the employer cannot objectively justify or rectify within six months. It is conducted in collaboration with employee representatives, and its outcome is specific corrective measures. It is the most stringent tool under Directive (EU) 2023/970—an “escalation” that no company wants to face.

Main objective: to ensure that unjustified pay gaps do not remain merely a number in a report, but are actually analyzed and eliminated.

You can find the text of the directive (Article 10—joint assessment of remuneration) on EUR-Lex.

When Does the Obligation Arise?

  • The report will show a difference of 5% or more in average pay between women and men in a particular occupational group
  • The employer does not justify the difference with objective, gender-neutral criteria
  • and does not correct it within 6 months of the report being submitted
  • → all three conditions must be met simultaneously = mandatory joint assessment

Why to Avoid It

A joint assessment is not an internal audit that a company conducts quietly on its own. It is conducted on a mandatory basis with employee representatives; its results are made available to employees and reported to the monitoring body. In the assessment, the company must disclose its compensation structure in detail—and commit to corrective measures with specific deadlines. It is costly, public, and externally managed.

The easier way: identify and correct discrepancies before the report flags them.

What the joint assessment includes

The directive specifies what the analysis must include:

  • an analysis of the proportion of women and men in individual occupational groups
  • Information on average pay levels for women and men by group, including supplemental and variable components
  • identifying differences and assessing whether they are based on objective, gender-neutral criteria
  • reasons for the identified discrepancies that cannot be objectively explained
  • corrective measures and a timeline for their implementation
  • evaluation of the effectiveness of measures identified in previous assessments

The basis is always a comparison of groups of jobs of equal value —without a high-quality job classification system, the assessment cannot be carried out, and the company will have to conduct it under time pressure and under the supervision of employee representatives.

How the correction takes place

If the assessment confirms unjustified disparities, the employer must remedy them within a reasonable time—in close cooperation with employee representatives, the labor inspectorate, or the equal treatment authority. Measures typically include:

  • adjustment (increase) of compensation for affected employees—the adjustment must not be made by reducing the wages of other employees
  • a review of the criteria in the compensation system that were causing the disparities
  • changes in processes (starting salaries, bonuses, promotions)
  • control mechanisms to prevent the differences from accumulating again

In addition, there is the individual level: employees who were paid in a discriminatory manner are entitled to back pay and compensation for damages—with the burden of proof reversed and placed on the employer.

How to Avoid a Review: Prevention in 5 Steps

  • Calculate the differences internally —using the same methodology as the future report, by work group
  • Review groups with holdings exceeding 5% —for each one, determine whether the difference is based on objective grounds (experience, performance, qualifications)
  • Document the rationale —anything that can be explained must be supported in writing
  • Plan your adjustments —address any unjustified discrepancies during payroll reviews while you still have control over the pace
  • Set preventive measures —rules for starting salaries and promotions—to prevent new disparities from arising

Six months to make corrections after a report is not enough time for any systemic changes. Companies that conduct a “dress rehearsal” a year in advance have time to iron out discrepancies gradually and without drama—and the assessment will never affect them.

The Role of Employee Representatives and Other Institutions

The word “joint” in the title is not just a formality. The assessment is conducted by the employer together with employee representatives—unions, the employee council, or representatives designated for this purpose. These representatives have access to the analyses, comment on the conclusions, and oversee corrective measures. Where there are no employee representatives, the procedure is governed by the Czech transposition of the directive; however, the intent of the directive is that the assessment should never be conducted solely “about employees without employees.”

Other institutions may also become involved: the labor inspectorate as a regulatory body and the equal treatment authority (in the Czech Republic, the Public Defender of Rights) as a support for employees. Furthermore, the results of the assessment are submitted to the monitoring body. For the company, this means one thing: all analyses and commitments must be in writing, consistent, and verifiable, because they will be read by more people than just HR.

Model Scenario: How a Company Slips Into an Assessment

An engineering firm with 280 employees submits its first report. In the “maintenance technicians and adjusters” category, there is a 7% disparity to the detriment of women. HR suspects that the gap has historical roots—the men on the team have been there longer and have accumulated performance bonuses—but has no evidence to support this: the job descriptions are ten years old, and the criteria for performance bonuses are not documented anywhere. There is therefore no objective justification, only assumptions.

The six-month deadline is in effect. Making up the wage differences would cost money that isn’t in the budget, so a solution is being postponed. The deadline will expire—and the company will be subject to a mandatory joint assessment: it must disclose its compensation structure to employee representatives, analyze each group, acknowledge in writing any differences without an objective reason, and commit to corrective action with deadlines that are also overseen by a monitoring body. Furthermore, the results will be made available to employees.

The irony of the whole situation: if the company had calculated the differences a year earlier, it could have resolved the same issue at a fraction of the cost—by gradually adjusting salaries during pay reviews and establishing criteria that it should have had in place long ago anyway.

Frequently asked questions

Does the 5% limit apply to the entire company?

No—each group of comparable jobs is evaluated separately. A company with an overall difference of 3% may have a difference of 8% across two groups, in which case it would be required to conduct an evaluation. Therefore, it is not enough to monitor a single aggregate figure.

What if we can explain the difference?

In that case, there is no obligation to conduct an assessment. The condition is that the justification must be based on objective, gender-neutral criteria and must be verifiable—for example, differences in seniority or measurable performance. “That’s just how it’s always been” is not a valid reason.

Who is subject to this requirement?

Employers subject to reporting requirements —that is, companies with 100 or more employees. Smaller companies are not required to conduct an assessment, but the principle of equal pay and employee entitlements still apply to them as well.

How long does the assessment take, and what is the outcome?

The duration depends on the size of the company and the quality of the source data—realistically, it takes months of work. The output is a written analysis of discrepancies by work group, the identification of unjustified discrepancies, and a plan for corrective actions with deadlines, the implementation of which is subsequently evaluated. The results are made available to employees and submitted to the monitoring body; they are therefore not internal notes, but a binding document.

Compensation Review and SmartFP

The best defense against a mandatory assessment is well-organized documentation: up-to-date job descriptions, documented job classifications, and a version-controlled compensation system. In SmartFP, these documents are created in a controlled manner—with approval, a change history, and verifiable notification to employees. Then, when you need to justify a discrepancy, you have evidence, not just impressions.

  • Documented compensation criteria, including versions and effective dates
  • Approval trail for each rule change
  • Guidelines for Cooperation with Employee Representatives
  • Records of Corrective Actions and Their Implementation